Dear Therapist: Please Don’t Lie To Me. Truth, Honesty, Integrity, Love And Connection In Therapy…And Why It Matters.

There’s a fucking cruel irony here, that today I am writing about lies and betrayal in therapy literally straight after posting up my last blog about not being able to fully appreciate safety in therapy even though I am safe, and the one before that writing about harm in therapy caused by other therapists but being so grateful to my therapist for being safe and consistent and all the good things…but I am beginning to think the universe hates me so why am I even surprised at this point?

What on earth am I talking about?

Have I lost mind?

Well, yes. Yes. I have…

Not again? Ha! Yep. Again.

I am so dysregulated at the moment that I barely know what to do or say but I need to get this out somewhere before I explode. I’ve been so … unwell…since Tuesday after my last session with Elle that I’ve been barely functional. I feel like I have had my legs taken out from beneath me. My stomach hurts. I feel jittery. I’ve had a consistent migraine and tension headache for four days now – and it’s only started to ease today. My back has seized up. Sleep is appalling. Nightmares are rife. I wake up in the middle of the night and just sob for hours.

Like it’s a mess.

What the hell has happened?

Has someone died or something?

Nope. But I am grieving.

I don’t think it’s really very easy to explain just how destabilising it is to have someone you love and trust betray your trust by lying to you…and how much grief that stirs up – especially if you have the sort of relational wounds that I do.

Of course, in this case the ‘someone that I love and trust’ is Elle.

I am devastated.

But I am also locked in an internal battle with myself. I don’t know if I am completely overreacting here or whether what I feel is justified?

Perhaps what’s happened isn’t all that big a deal… or maybe I am just incapable, these days, of noticing when I am standing right slap bang in the middle of a red flag factory until I am fully wrapped in them from head to toe. Do I just not see the colour red anymore? Or is it a washed out pink now, and I am trying to romanticise the flags as pretty blush-coloured bunting?

I feel like this is really cryptic. It’s not meant to be. But my brain is all over the place. My system is in chaos and disarray and I just feel really fucking sad that I hardly know what to say here.

Part of me wanted to write yet another email to Elle today rather than blog. But she’s away and my telling her what’s going on since the last message we exchanged isn’t going to help matters any. I don’t want to disturb her time away. The last break we had was fine (still not written about that) but May was a disaster (finding myself on the online therapist forum)…and frankly, I don’t want to go there EVER again.

Right now, I am not sure if I can even make it to session on Tuesday, though. My system is off its tits and because it’s free to go spiral off in any direction it wants to for the next few days I am struggling to hold tight to the sense that Elle is safe at all, or cares.

I guess I should just cut to the chase, here, but it might take a bit as I can only focus in short bursts and want to escape this emotional agony and so keep getting dragged into ASMR rug cleaning videos, or anything else that will distract from the fact that my heart is broken…over what is essentially a white lie.

The thing is, does it even matter what colour a lie is in therapy? Therapy is (supposed to be) built on trust and honesty – they are the cornerstones of the process – alongside unconditional positive regard…and yet here we are.

I can’t actually believe it.

Right, RB, stop fucking about, just spell it out. Deep breaths…here we go. Brace positions.

A few months ago, Elle set up an ongoing Zoom link for our Friday check in sessions rather than having to send me a new link each week – makes sense. When she did that it meant that all our sessions went into an online calendar that was shared with me. I can see months and months ahead that our time is blocked out. No problems there.

A couple of months ago I got a notification that my session on Friday 10th October was cancelled and it had a line through it on my calendar. Fine. I figured Elle had something on that day and it was no big deal. We’d always said Fridays might change here and there so it was no sweat.

When I next saw Elle in person, she didn’t mention the cancellation and I assumed that at some point down the line she would tell me about it as it was still a way off.  But I was certain she’d mention it, either just to confirm the skipped week, or perhaps we would reschedule the slot to some other time in the week.

The weeks have been rolling by and nothing has been said by Elle at all. Part of me wondered this last week if maybe the thing had changed again and perhaps the call was happening as there had been no discussion about it – although nothing had changed on the calendar to suggest that. And the Friday round Christmas got crossed out so I knew that Elle was actively doing things her end.

A week ago, on Friday, I was in session face-to-face with Elle. It was during that appalling week where I had lost the plot and basically felt borderline suicidal in my Tuesday session and had had a Thursday check in and then a Friday session too. It was a bad week! She said she was going away that weekend to see a friend and then mentioned seeing another friend this weekend…but no reference was made to the Friday being off or her being away in the week and so it confused me a bit as in that moment Elle must have been thinking about seeing this friend and knew when it was she’d be going. It was also a Friday morning that I was sitting with her in the room so it’s not like she could forget that we meet on Fridays.

She had to be avoiding talking to me about it – but maybe it was because I had had such a rotten week and the idea of telling me about it felt like it might be destabilising? I dunno. Either way, she kept quiet. Still, I just imagined she’d tell me on Tuesday that Friday was off – even if that felt a bit last minute and a bit crap given how hard things have been as it really didn’t give us much of an opportunity to put anything in place… not that I would have needed much. It’s only a check in and really a text message would have done instead.

Anyway, I went to my session on Tuesday and it was ok but something felt a little off. Perhaps I was just waiting to see if Elle was going to tell me about Friday. She didn’t. Nothing was said at all. At that point I wondered what the hell was going on and why she hadn’t said anything. Maybe she knew that our calendars were synced and I already knew?…but then surely, you’d always mention a break in person? Or at least via email or text?

Whenever I leave my session on a Tuesday Elle ALWAYS says, “See you on Friday”… like ALWAYS. Yet as I left on Tuesday she didn’t. So, I knew that Friday was off but she hadn’t told me herself.

Ugh.

Crap.

But I guess I already knew and had been bracing for it.

But why was she avoiding saying anything? I know breaks can be tricky, but our last one was fine and missing a check in isn’t the end of the world…

What I wasn’t expecting, however, was to receive a breezy email later that afternoon from Elle:

Hello lovely girl 💕🥰

I’ve just been invited away for a long weekend this week with a friend I hardly ever see, which means I won’t be able to make our usual call at 9 on Friday. 

Sorry to not give you more notice, or write you something that feels holding, and I hope that feels ok and not too jarring? Rest assured I will return on Monday morning, if not refreshed maybe a little perkier and less coldish.

Tightest of squishes, 

(and absolutely no Halloween gooeyness)

🎃👻🫂💕🍂

Elle xxxxx

To say my stomach fell through the floor is not an understatement. I was just about to go online and teach and as I read that I felt like I was going to be sick.

Because what was this?

She’d had all the time in the world to tell me about the cancelled check in, plenty of notice. She could have told me right that afternoon when I was sitting in the room with her as it was clearly on her mind given she consciously omitted her usual, “See you on Friday”. And there had been plenty of time to write something holding (not that that was at all necessary). We could have rearranged the call months back – like there were so many ways of navigating this. And if the message had have been the truth, yes it would have been a little jarring but nothing like the whiplash I was experiencing in that moment seeing that my therapist of two years who knows me so intimately, knows how important trust and honesty is to me, knows how badly harmed I have been by therapists and their lies, and how very difficult I have been finding things lately…had chosen to lie to me like this.

And not only that, but this was all coming from a therapist who says how important honesty is, and integrity, and trust…like wtaf was going on?

Please make it make sense.

And in the big scheme of things, I really get that it’s not a huge lie but my system can’t seem to differentiate between a whopper and a barely noticeable one because to the little parts of my system and the traumatised parts – a lie is a lie. And if she’ll lie about this what else has she said that isn’t true?

So, as I was just about to start work I fired off a quick reply:

I guess you don’t know that your Zoom calendar updates my end too for our stuff, and I’ve known that this Friday has been off the cards for weeks now. Please don’t lie to me. I can handle changes – because we always said Fridays would be moveable and not guaranteed. I’m less good at whatever this is. And I get you probably didn’t want to tell me because there never seems a good time when things are crap – but I’d rather know than you avoid telling me because you think I’ll react badly. I wouldn’t have. 

That’s all I could say in the moment – but it was at least better than running away and completely retreating from it – which is what I wanted to do.

And then I had to try and teach three lessons on the bounce as my internal scaffolding collapsed and I wanted to run away and curl up in a ball and cry.

I can’t explain how difficult it is to be present online 1:1 with a student when my emotional world is in meltdown. There is literally nowhere to hide.

Not long after I sent that message email flashed up another notification. Elle again:

I’m so sorry honey, you’re right that she didn’t just ask. I’m so sorry I lied and said that. I didn’t want you to think I’d forgotten to tell you and for you to feel unimportant and like you don’t matter, But the truth is I had forgotten, and then tried to cover it up.

Will you forgive me for being cowardly? I feel as if I really fucked up.

Not long after this my phone rang and it was Elle but as I was teaching and I couldn’t answer and even if I could have I wasn’t sure if it was a deliberate call from her…or one of those accidental dials because she hadn’t text me, “Can I call you?” not that she’s ever called me unplanned before – and she didn’t leave a voicemail or follow it up with a text.

As it was, I was teaching until 8pm with no gaps and by the time I finished and would have been able to return the call I knew that she was off doing ‘the thing’ she does with my friend (groan) and wouldn’t have been available anyway. Not that I would ever call her ad-hoc even if I wanted to because ‘boundaries’ and ‘good client behaviour’ and all that stuff.

You can probably imagine, that by the time I got done with work I was in a right state so I just took myself off to bed. Sometimes there isn’t anything to be gained by messaging in an upset state and I also knew that I wouldn’t get a reply anyway as Elle wasn’t ‘there’ and that would have triggered me even more.

On Wednesday morning Elle emailed me again:

I’m so sorry I let you down lovely girl, and that I didn’t honour our trust.

Please know though that me lying was never about protecting myself from you or your reaction, it was (and is always) about me feeling like making mistakes or being less than perfectly caring means that I’m not enough. 

I’m always fighting that programming, and when my resistance is low, like it is right now, I fuck up. I lie to cover the fact that I’ve been careless or clumsy, because in my world that was the worst thing I could ever do.

I know that for you a lie could mean that everything I have said is now being called into question, and that your trust in me has potentially been broken irrevocably. But please know that I will not and will never avoid talking about these things with you, taking responsibility and doing my best to mend your trust. Because this is just as important for me as it is for you.

I really hope you want to see me on Tuesday.

Elle xxxx

I didn’t really know what to say in that moment. I was so upset still. It’s hard to explain what a sucker punch to the gut being lied to by the person I have trusted the most with my most vulnerable self felt like, and I was without words. I could register that that was an apology but somehow it didn’t land. I guess there were so many parts activated that it would take more than an email to mend.

I had hardly slept on Tuesday night and so once I got the kids off to school I took myself off to bed again, lay under my weighted blanket and cried myself to sleep.

That probably sounds really dramatic but there’s been a lot of tears this week and a lot of crying in bed. But I think those of you that have deep relational wounds and are deeply attached to your therapists will understand what it might feel like for this to happen. It just felt so much like the special thing that I thought we had built, that means so much to me, in reality means nothing much at all to her…because I would never choose to lie if it meant risking our relationship – and from her email she as clearly aware what this might mean for my trust in her and our relationship.

And I know it was only a small lie…and she’s clearly tried to reach out to put it right…but is that enough? I dunno. Not for some parts of me. I was so far gone by that point all that really would have reached through this mess would have been to properly talk and ideally see her in person…and that wasn’t on the cards. If there is a rupture I will never ask for contact like that even if it is what parts of me are screaming out for. If Elle doesn’t offer if then I am not going to ask especially if I am already feeling the very things she didn’t want me to feel, ‘unimportant’ and ‘like I don’t matter’.

When I fell asleep I ended up having a terrible dream about being in a train where the sliding doors wouldn’t close. The train started moving and it was windy and unsafe. I knew I needed to raise alarm but I couldn’t get the control panel to work to stop the train. No matter what button I pressed the system wouldn’t let me raise the alarm. I tried to manually shut the sliding doors even though it was really unsafe to do so and once I did it I held it together with a tiny sticker with a handwritten note on – ‘broken- unsafe- do not use’.

It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to see what that’s about. I didn’t feel able to reply properly to Elle’s emails or tell her how I was feeling but I sent her the dream and the Chat GPT analysis…because could it be any better of a metaphor?

Elle replied with something that felt sort of holding but also sort of scary…she told me that she wishes I could see into her heart and see what’s really there – which sounds fine – but then said that “I want to never let you down and to always be a safe person who you feel loved and seen by, but honestly I don’t know if that is possible” and all my alarms started going all at once.

Like total panic.

I had to teach again but I could hardly concentrate.

I felt sick.

All I wanted to do was reach out to Elle, to speak to her, to try and stop this going where my brain was going…and then I did the thing…and I didn’t realise that was what was happening at the time but I fell into the “Shit Shit SHIT she might leave, it sounds like she’s backing away, I need to not be too much and make this all ok before she gives up on me.”

How familiar are we with this pattern? Someone hurts us but if we so much as get a hint of their being wobbly we do all we can to make them feel better even if it means shelving our own hurt and pain. We must preserve the relationship at all costs even if that means denying our own need.

Ugh.

I thought I was being super adult at the time and untriggered (!) and actually all I was doing was fawning. My scared little girl part was doing everything she could to prevent herself from getting left and then went quietly away to her bedroom to cry on her own… again…

Like I don’t not believe what I said in that message, I do, but I didn’t give anything like enough space to the reality of what I was feeling, how much I was struggling, or what I NEEDED in that moment.

This is what I sent:

I think you set entirely too high expectations of yourself. As humans we are always going to make mistakes and let people down and forget things. Because that’s what happens… and when we’re tired and hormones are doing weird things on top it’s even harder. The thing is, all of this could have been so easily avoided by just saying, “RB I thought I’d told you this, and I’ve realised that I haven’t, but I’m not going to be here on Friday” and really what’s the worst that would have happened? Like I might have felt a bit sad about it but we would have talked it though and that would have been that. The world wouldn’t have ended. Instead, you thought it better to lie to me than tell me the simple truth. And I get why you did it. And I get that in some ways it’s not a big deal. But this whole thing is about trust and I have to believe that you don’t lie to me about stuff to stand a chance of believing that you are actually someone safe. Because how am I meant to believe anything you say if you’ll lie about something so minor? And I understand the thing about feeling not enough and having a reaction to feeling like you’ve not been perfect and so it probably feels big in the moment because of the old conditioning around that… but I’ve told you before and I’m saying it again now- I don’t need you to be perfect and I don’t expect it either – I just need you to be real and honest with me. However that looks. Because it’s hurt me that you haven’t trusted me with the truth. And of course it’s triggered all my stuff which I know is exactly the thing you were trying to avoid in the first place… so it’s a bit shit. In your message you said you hoped I would want to see you on Tuesday. And whilst part of me wants to run a million miles in the other direction because I’m hurt, of course I want to see you. Because this is the irritating thing about all this – I’d like to think by now it’s not so fragile that stuff can’t be worked through. But it feels sometimes when this stuff gets triggered – your ‘not enough’ stuff – that you retreat and everything feels different. Like you’re there but it’s not quite you. And I guess maybe there’s a little bit of you that’s hiding too. But I don’t say it lightly when I tell you that I love you and it’s not conditional. But I will have to force feed you soggy orange fondant if you lie to me again xxx 😘 

Elle didn’t reply to that on Wednesday so you can only imagine how that felt. Like here I was struggling to even function, crying, and feeling sick and yet trying to make it better her end, trying to fudge a repair and she didn’t even acknowledge it. I didn’t send it late either, 4pm, but apparently it was fine to leave it or leave me in it.

I got that horrible feeling that the thing they (therapists) all do was happening – you know? Where there’s a rupture and the therapist pulls back? They start only replying in office hours, and then in a way that isn’t consistent with their usual tone and manner? The next thing you know you’re in for a boundary talk and everything that had been so much a part of the therapy gets taken away…and not because of anything you even did. The moment they feel the container is leaking or the frame is wobbly they double down. I really hoped that this wasn’t going to happen but I was ready. Been there, done that, seen it all before, got several t-shirts.

The next day Elle replied and she explained some stuff that we’ve spoken about before and I think it was an attempt to justify what had happened. And it made sense. Like we’ve all told lies and we often do it because it’s hard to be seen as we are – especially if we feel like we’ve cocked up. Like we try and cover our tracks and hope that no one notices. I won’t put that here because it feels especially personal to Elle and doesn’t add anything but I think I felt just a bit unseen in the whole thing – like I needed something that acknowledged my pain, not why it happened.

I replied:

Well, I think maybe it’s better to tell the truth and deal with the consequences which are probably always going to be way less bad than you imagine (these days at least – or at least where you and me are concerned), than lie and have the fall out of that. I think most people can cope with people being fallible and making mistakes but struggle far more with being deceived even if it’s meant well. Or that’s how it is for me. I’ve been lied to such a lot in these seemingly benign ways and then what’s actually underneath has been so bad and so painful that it makes me really scared. I don’t want to feel like I’m now having to watch really carefully for patterns repeating but it’s my default. Like this all looks horribly familiar to Anita’s burnout trajectory… even if it’s not. It never starts with a huge thing, it’s always small stuff. So, I’m on high alert for the next thing – which is generally a subtle form of retreat. 

This week all just feels like a double whammy of ouch. Maybe I’m just more sensitive to what you see as shrinking in for a second because I feel it acutely as a pulling back. It’s like you disappear, or maybe you’re there but only in 2D and in black and white. And it feels really hard because when this stuff happens all I want to do is disappear and I know that doesn’t really help me so instead I try really hard not to, but also try really hard to not come at things from a really triggered place and ground a bit first…and when I do that and can’t find anything but the hollowed out version of you or feel you’re gone altogether it’s really bad because I feel like I am putting my really vulnerable self out there only to be met with distance. That’s how it feels anyway. I guess it’s probably because in that moment so much of my not enough and too much stuff is triggered that I’m fearing the very worst.

It feels a bit like trying to communicate down one of those telephones with two cups and bit of string and I can kind of see you off in the distance but not quite hear what’s coming down the line and you’re too far away to see your face. I just want to hold your hand and know that this didn’t all happen because of something I’ve done wrong or because you’ve had enough and just need a break from caring for me. 

😞

Elle replied and assured me that she wasn’t burning out and that what I feared was happening isn’t and that she’d be there on Tuesday.

But then if she isn’t burning out why did she choose to lie to me?

Knowing Elle was away now with her friend I didn’t bother to reply…and the great news about this not being fully resolved is that my system has had plenty of time to catastrophise about everything that has happened because Elle isn’t here, we haven’t spoken, and I am left hanging with this turning it over in my mind in a million different ways and looking at it through all the lenses of all my little parts like I am staring into a kaleidoscope of fear and heartbreak and turning the dial.

Tbh this all feels a bit like I’ve been in a hit and run and she’s gone, “I can see you might have a few broken bones there and it looks like you’re bleeding out from your chest, but just sit tight for a few days and we can get this patched up next Tuesday.”

And that isn’t great.

I guess from my emails it looks like I am largely fine, in my adult and can see this as a rupture that is perfectly navigable and survivable.

Only that’s not the whole story.

What’s written between the lines?

Oh my god, there’s a story.

The thing I keep circling back round to is that this relationship matters way more to me than it does to her. And I get it. That’s how therapy works. Like this is how it has always been. It’s us (clients) that get really attached and bring all our early wounds into the therapy and the therapist who becomes the stand-in parent. I am just one of Elle’s clients and I am her work. I know that. But to me she is such a lot. Like she is so important…and I usually feel ok about that. I usually feel like my feelings are ok, welcomed, not too much, and that they are reciprocated to a degree – but this week has just triggered the biggest amount of shame in me.

Like how do I find myself here again?

Why do I never learn?

Why have I opened my heart up to someone who clearly doesn’t appreciate what that actually means? I’ve always felt that Elle holds my heart and our relationship so carefully (and I really need to write about our 2 year anniversary and the break we had) but it felt like this week she had a choice to make: lean into and trust in the connection even if she did feel like it might cause a bit of upset or choose to disconnect altogether from me and the relationship in favour of a quick get out of jail free moment. And she chose the disconnect.

Clearly, I really struggle with lying (not just being lied to but even telling lies). It does things in my body. I feel physically uncomfortable. My stomach goes tight. My heart races. My mouth goes a bit dry. I feel a bit prickly behind my eyes. And I just don’t feel ok. Don’t get me wrong though. I am a good liar. Or I used to be, once upon a time. I used to lie like my survival depended on it. Especially when I was consumed by anorexia and was self-harming… I used to be able to look people dead in the eye and lie, because I told it like a truth.

I can’t do that now. Or I could. But I absolutely refuse to.

I have never once told a lie to Elle. I don’t deliberately withhold things from her. One of the things I have vowed to myself in my therapy is that even if the truth feels uncomfortable, it’s worth saying. It might feel scary or downright toe-curlingly shame inducing but I feel like if I tell the truth, and people stay then they are my people and there’s really nothing all that bad that I could ever say anyway. I truly believe that honesty and vulnerability are the only paths to true connection (ha, hello Brene Brown!)…and that’s what I want. I don’t want a half-formed ghost version of a connection. I want the real, warts and all one.

If I feel I have to lie or bend myself to preserve a relationship then I don’t really want it anyway because I’ve done that my whole life growing up. I did it so much with Em – I never lied but I held back a lot…until I didn’t… and the more I let Em see me, the more I told her my reality the less she could cope with me and my feelings. I could have saved myself a lot of pain and misery if I’d not taken years to build up to telling her how I felt. In the end she saw me as a tick but I had always been a tick hadn’t I, she just didn’t know! Certainly those feelings I had for her came about nine months after I met her and yet it took eight years for it to blow up and break the therapy because I hid so well. I won’t do that now.

When I saw Anita I went into it without my armour but as she started to lose her capacity I started to put it back on a piece at a time. I armoured up and withheld stuff in order to be ‘easier’ for her. I didn’t lie. I just didn’t always tell her what was going on because I didn’t want to push her away. I basically reverted to type. I made myself smaller. I hid my struggles and my needs to try and give her space to get through what was going on for her. It didn’t work though, did it? It just delayed the agony ultimately.

With Elle it’s been slow and steady work. I feel like it has been such an exercise in trust and bravery, especially given all that’s come before. I have opened up to her in a way I didn’t think I would be able to. And so to have her so easily lie to me feels like a kick in the teeth. I have tried so hard to connect in an authentic way…and I believed that she was doing the same. But now I just feel like ‘work’ and someone whom she can easily discard and disconnect from. And it hurts.

My most unkind protector – the Inner Critic is having an absolute field day spouting their most favourite lines “You absolute loser, you can’t even pay someone to be in a relationship with you and care. Can’t you see what this is? It’s a game that she plays with you for a couple of hours a week to make you think you matter but the reality is, you’re just money to her. You pay the bills. If you mattered to her she’d show you through the most basic behaviour. She wouldn’t like to you. We don’t lie to people that really matter.”

And it’s really really hard to disagree with that voice.

Part of me wants to think maybe it’s the very opposite that is true. Maybe Elle lied because I matter to her. Maybe she didn’t want to hurt me or make me feel any of this painful stuff. I don’t think the logic behind what she’s done is great but I can see why it could be the case.

Either way, this week has activated all my really painful stuff and I haven’t had anywhere at all to put it.

Part of me is really angry too – well isn’t Anger just Hurt’s bodyguard? Like, why did this have to happen? Why couldn’t this therapy just be what it said on the tin? What do I keep doing wrong to make it so that therapists treat me like this? Why can’t I just be safe and loved and matter enough to not have someone hurt me in this way?

It’s hard not to see Elle’s actions as coming from a place of just being completely bored of having to think about how to manage my attachment stuff. Like, her initial message said, she hadn’t had time to write something… and so in her mind any time she leaves I demand time and energy just to get a weekend away. So perhaps this is my fault. Maybe if I wasn’t so high need then she wouldn’t have felt the need to lie. She probably just told her other Friday appointments that she wasn’t available and that was that.

So, this all makes me feel rotten. I feel my usual wonderful combo of ‘too much’ and ‘not enough’. Too much need and too much work and not important enough for anyone to truly care or love me.

I don’t know what the answer is here.

It’s only Sunday. I feel broken…and it’s a long way til Tuesday. Of course, I have no sense of the Elle I know being out there at all now because this is what happens when there’s distance and a rupture. My brain is serving ‘danger’ and all the rest of it.

I soooooo want to believe that we will be ok.  I want to believe that if I tell her how hurt I am that she will do her best to repair this and take the time to work through it with me – even if it takes a really long time… I need her not to be defensive or reactive…but I have no idea what state she is in and whether she has the energy or capacity to go with me where I need to go. Because let’s be real, this has hit on a very deep wound and it’s going to take some healing. I feel like this is something that will be dredged up over and over again. I will be constantly looking for reassurance and testing.

I hate this.

Part of me is reluctant to post this blog up because I’m worried that if Elle comes across it – now, or later – she’ll see it as a criticism of her, or somehow see it as sharing too much of what’s gone on between us with the outside world. I imagine she’d feel fucked off that I’ve copied some of the messages she’s sent to me here but I honestly don’t know what to do or where to turn for support or reassurance at the moment.

If Elle and I do make it through this I don’t want her to stop messaging me because she thinks our communications will only end up on the blog because that isn’t how it is. I’ve always been so careful here to not really talk any detail about what she says to me – I’ve protected her/us in a way that I never did Em or Anita because I’ve felt so protective of our relationship and what we’ve created together. I value her and the relationship such a lot…and right now I just don’t know what to do.

I don’t know how we’ll come through this because I feel like there’s a massive part of me that will struggle to trust her ever again. How can I be sure of anything now?

Perhaps a white lie is no big deal. Maybe I am just too sensitive. Maybe my trauma makes me too reactive. All I know is that I feel completely at sea and completely alone. I wish Elle understood how in a simple bending of the truth she’s taken a machete to my trust in her and set fire to the deep connection we were weaving together.

I’m sure Elle is having a wonderful time away, though…lucky her.

I think this may be the longest post I have ever written – shoot me now.x

31 thoughts on “Dear Therapist: Please Don’t Lie To Me. Truth, Honesty, Integrity, Love And Connection In Therapy…And Why It Matters.

  1. Virgolady's avatar Virgolady October 12, 2025 / 9:55 am

    I have read – and felt – every single word of this and just wanted to respond instantly to say that you are not alone, and I am so glad you have reached out. I have “adult” stuff to do today, but am thinking of you and will reply properly – which is what you deserve – as soon as I am able to. Hang on in there – we are with you. Sending 💕 xx

    Liked by 2 people

  2. SH's avatar SH October 12, 2025 / 10:23 am

    Huge hugs. Read every word and you make 10000% make sense as those of us with complex trauma understand ❤️. We hope Elle can repair. It is sometimes super baffling how therapists don’t seem to understand some really basic things when you trust that they do. Then they reveal it and us clients are like “I thought you truly understood, even though I know you can’t feel it the way I do.”

    Liked by 1 person

    • rubberbandsandchewinggum's avatar rubberbandsandchewinggum October 12, 2025 / 12:05 pm

      It’s been so hard this week… today has been the first day without a nightmare. Eek. Thank you for always having my back xx

      Liked by 1 person

      • SH's avatar SH October 12, 2025 / 3:08 pm

        🫂🫂🫂🫂

        Liked by 1 person

      • SH's avatar SH October 16, 2025 / 12:08 pm

        Hang in there ❤️❤️

        Liked by 1 person

      • SH's avatar SH October 16, 2025 / 1:54 pm

        Big hug. We’re a “highly sensitive person” according to our therapist, and oh boy do we wish we could dial our sensitivity down too 🫂

        Liked by 1 person

      • rubberbandsandchewinggum's avatar rubberbandsandchewinggum October 16, 2025 / 2:20 pm

        It’s hard feeling so much isn’t it? Like I like that I feel and care and all the rest of it because I genuinely believe love and connection is what life is about but it means that we’re so vulnerable to hurt. Xx

        Liked by 1 person

      • SH's avatar SH October 16, 2025 / 3:22 pm

        It is 💔. I’ve a similar opinion on life being about love, meaning, building a better world, and I often feel I’m too intense for caring so much about stuff.

        Liked by 1 person

      • SH's avatar SH October 17, 2025 / 7:17 am

        True! When we first started seeing our T, she used “connection seeking” instead of “needy” or “attention-seeking”. It helped us feel less shame. ❤️

        Like

  3. SunsetCherryBlossom's avatar SunsetCherryBlossom October 12, 2025 / 12:38 pm

    Oh RB. I don’t even know if a full bucket of Ben and Jerrys will help here?!

    I know how hard this feels. Knowing you have been lied to is a horrible feeling, it really is. It feels like a kick in the teeth for the trust you have built up.

    I’m just going to suggest one thing – and that is to keep up communication with Elle. Shes made big mistake. But I guess it comes down to – how big a mistake is too big? Is this something along the lines of forgetting how you take your coffee? Or is it bigger than you can cope with? Was she just distracted by some kind of irritating but ultimately fixable thing in her own life (maybe her central heating broke?!) and dropped the ball a bit but is more than capable of picking it up again?

    just keep talking…

    Liked by 2 people

    • rubberbandsandchewinggum's avatar rubberbandsandchewinggum October 12, 2025 / 1:33 pm

      It’s way more than coffee… it’s really about the whole foundation of the relationship. I guess I’ve just got to see how Tuesday plays out. I’m all over the place – as you can see from the post. Part of me just wants a cuddle and to be told it’s ok but another is really rattled and just can’t see how this resolves. Trust is so important. 😞

      Liked by 1 person

  4. joyfully9bb2c6d310's avatar joyfully9bb2c6d310 October 13, 2025 / 5:11 am

    I’m so sorry you are going through this and hope you can repair. I again found myself relating so much to what you wrote… earlier today I was thinking about asking my ex therapist what I should do better, hide, or change about my presentation in the future so as not to be harmed again by future therapists… and berating myself for being so invested when that ex therapist didn’t care about me at all…

    Anyway, just commenting to say I don’t think your reactions are too much at all, and it’s not reason for therapists to be retreating from you.

    Hang in there!

    Liked by 2 people

    • rubberbandsandchewinggum's avatar rubberbandsandchewinggum October 13, 2025 / 6:26 am

      Thank you. It’s just so difficult isn’t it? I’m sorry this sort of thing has happened to you too. It’s hard not to just reach a point where you give up with the whole thing when it happens over and over again as it just seems to reenforce the message we’re trying so hard to get away from. It’s bad enough experiencing it as a kid but as an adult it’s kind of soul destroying. X

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Laura's avatar Laura October 14, 2025 / 5:28 pm

    Hi flower, I’ve been reading but haven’t had the brain capacity to comment. But have been thinking about you lots today and really really hope that you got to session xxx

    Liked by 2 people

    • rubberbandsandchewinggum's avatar rubberbandsandchewinggum October 14, 2025 / 8:51 pm

      Thanks L. I did go. Man it was hard. I spent first ten minutes trembling. Exhausting. Was there ages. Think it’s going to be ok … but Jesus! The worst of it is that I feel like I need a lot of contact right now to reassure my system and I don’t think that’s possible 🙁

      Liked by 1 person

      • Laura's avatar Laura October 15, 2025 / 1:39 pm

        Well done for making it ❤️‍🩹

        Why the lack of contact, Elle is normally very supportive of that? X

        Liked by 2 people

      • rubberbandsandchewinggum's avatar rubberbandsandchewinggum October 15, 2025 / 2:35 pm

        Oh no, she is. We’ve emailed. I’ve told her I’m likely to be a clingy nightmare. It’s just right now I feel like I need to actually see her a lot in person to show the wobbly parts it’s ok. We can’t see each other f2f on Friday and so zoom is going to be hard. Basically I need a little space in the corner of the room to curl up in and keep checking she’s there. It feels a very long time til Tuesday.

        Liked by 2 people

  6. Me's avatar Me October 15, 2025 / 4:55 am

    Ugh, I felt this. I’d have felt sucker punched too. What stood out for me is the need for her to do some reflection on her fear of upsetting you, and to do some work around building her strength around that. She cant work professionally or in a way that is helpful to you if she’s choosing to tiptoe around normal parts of a relationship – she needs to be robust enough to say to herself that schedule changes etc are normal. She does sound a tad burnout in her fear of upsetting you. I hope this has given her one heck of a sucker punch too, and she uses it to rebalance her emotions and reserves and step up for you. You didn’t deserve this and it isn’t your fault x

    Liked by 2 people

    • rubberbandsandchewinggum's avatar rubberbandsandchewinggum October 16, 2025 / 8:56 am

      Yeah. She genuinely forgot to tell me about the change and then when she did remember she just thought it would be easier to paste over it because she knows how being forgotten about or feeling unimportant is hard for me. She knows that it was a total fuck up though and the fall out from it has been much worse than having been told the truth. We talked about how it’s ok to disappoint people but how damaging broken trust is. It’s going to be ok. I understand what’s happened after a really huge session on Tuesday. I’m left with a bit of a hangover though and am struggling with just feeling like i need load of reassurance and contact. My heart hurts – not from what’s happened but the disconnect just from being apart. Like when these ruptures happen it feels so hard to go back into the world and not be able to keep tapping into the safe space to soothe the parts that panic. Ugh. I just need a hug. So once again I’m in bed under my weighted blanket having a little cry. 😞

      Liked by 2 people

      • SH's avatar SH October 16, 2025 / 2:46 pm

        🫂🫂🫂🫂

        Like

      • chloe83's avatar chloe83 October 23, 2025 / 4:16 am

        This sounds so hard and I can totally understand the feeling you must be experiencing. It sounds like she got caught in a white lie but that can do so much damage to those of us who struggle to trust the relationships. Understandable it has shaken the foundation of your trust with her right now. Recently I emailed my therapist to schedule (she normally replies within 24–48 hours). I also sometimes send journal-style reflections, and this message came after a session where we’d had a rupture — so I suspect she might have assumed it was a reflection and didn’t open it right away. Five days later she finally replied; when I confirmed, her out-of-office autoreply came back saying she’d been away. At our next session she seemed briefly unclear about what I was referring to and then gave a quick “oh yes, I was” which made me think she hadn’t read the email until much later and used the auto-reply to explain the delay. It has really made me question things. I’m glad she didn’t double down or get defensive and immediately fessed up to her mistake. It will take time for her to rebuild back your trust but the relationship is strong and can survive this.

        Liked by 2 people

      • rubberbandsandchewinggum's avatar rubberbandsandchewinggum October 25, 2025 / 9:53 pm

        Relationships are hard aren’t they? And therapeutic relationships even more so. Elle completely owned what she did and apologised but even still I’m struggling a lot right now because this whole thing has triggered all the anxiety about rejection and abandonment because it feels like similar territory to when Anita started losing her way. So now I feel massively clingy and needy and dysregulated but also like I need to be really careful not to be “too much” and part of me feels mad about it because this wasn’t my fault to begin with. Elle and I have been in a really good place and then this happened and ugh- fucked it up. My anxiety is off the charts and I don’t really know how to get what I need to make it better. I don’t think Elle has any idea how much I’m struggling but then her focus is necessarily elsewhere… which is also hard.

        Liked by 1 person

  7. Scotcare's avatar Scotcare October 18, 2025 / 11:19 pm

    Aw no,I was so sad to read this . You are not being over sensitive at all. Elle f*d up, but I am glad the in person appointment helped. Only you know if you can really move forward but from what you have written on the past,she definitely cares and is definitely trying to do her best for you,so maybe the overall picture helps So sorry this happened though. I would have been pretty upset too.

    Liked by 2 people

    • rubberbandsandchewinggum's avatar rubberbandsandchewinggum October 19, 2025 / 10:57 am

      Thanks 🙏 yeah it’s been pretty rotten. I felt completely blindsided by it and it’s meant I’ve felt really unsettled even though we have had a good talk about it. It’s the fall out that’s the problem. My entire system feels scared and like Elle is gone – even though she’s not – and I feel super clingy and upset but can’t really do much about that. I think I needed to see her twice in person this week tbh. It’s one of those times where if you had a little kid you’d just hold them and rock them until they regulated and fell asleep … instead my inner children are screaming on their own. They’ll shut up eventually – some of them already know that no one ever comes and don’t even bother crying. God, being mental is exhausting! 😬😅

      Liked by 1 person

  8. Scotcare's avatar Scotcare October 19, 2025 / 2:18 pm

    Hope you can be gentle to yourself. And it’s absolutely understandable you feel like that. Even though you get logically what happened, it’s a massive thing emotionally.

    Liked by 2 people

  9. SH's avatar SH November 8, 2025 / 7:12 pm

    Thinking of you and all the yous.

    Like

Leave a reply to Me Cancel reply